Scrambling vs climbing reddit. Semantics are indeed weird.
Scrambling vs climbing reddit approach shoes are way different for the good and the bad. This ain't "easy climbing" and it's not exposed, that's Class 4; again MFotH: Class 4. Takes the use of hands, but if you slip and fall, you really aren't likely to get seriously hurt or die. The difference is grade. Works great for climbing and scrambling in the mountains too. There are about a million class 3/4 routes in CO of all types of exposure/style. St. 11 V's on my first go and bailed off easy 5. That is why climbing shoes fit so snug. I find Tower Ridge to be a great scramble but Great Ridge on Garbh Bheinn feels more like a climb to me (steeper and more sustained exposure). Open menu Open navigation Go to Reddit Home. com Feb 23, 2023 · Scrambling vs Climbing. It’s a mental thing. Overall it takes courage and fortitude but is an absolute adventure. I find it weird when people call only roped climbing “climbing”. The Flight zips open like a clamshell, I take this for single day cragging when the approach is relatively short. Do any of you have any training ideas which would translate to scrambling in the mountains? We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. Depending on format (scramble vs iso), if scramble treat attempts at boulders as incredibly important. Down climbing makes me a bit nervous. Climbing just doesn't prepare you to walk uphill for 10+ hours a day carrying a heavy pack. If you had previously been climbing on the rock, and left chalk marks on the rock, the officer could reasonably infer you were climbing. The climbing wasn’t difficult but the route as a whole was physically strenuous, but nothing impossible. 5(YDS) technical scramble with various rappel points. Understanding the difference between hiking, scrambling and rock climbing could save a Sep 7, 2015 · Scrambling vs climbing is very subjective and what the individual finds to be a scramble is quite personal. You need to get comfortable with the exposure. Then scrambling becomes more within your ability. Building a quality approach shoe is an art—and a science. If I will be doing any significant scrambling, I will take boots because the stiffer sole makes it easier and more comfortable to stand on smaller edges. Some shoes/boots for technical terrain that allows scrambling also is a good one for me. I've used both and definitely prefer the approach shoes for scrambling if there isn't a long approach beforehand. Crib Goch on Snowdon. Recently I joined a climbing gym to start learning, and intend to take a 3-day mountaineering course in May through a mountaineering club in my state. Scrambling is between hiking and rock climbing. . we ARE NOT looking to do any serious rock climbing, just finding some rocky trails :) i've done my fair share of hiking on the east coast and know we can't find something exactly like JT. I have wider feet, value climbing ability more than hiking comfort, and prefer lower weight footwear. There’s an incentive for climbing gyms, which are businesses, to make the lower grades more accessible than their outdoor equivalent. You’ll need ropes, harnesses, and specialized climbing gear to navigate vertical rock faces. You nearly always need to scramble up some chossy shit to get to the actual climb. The French use this system for most things (apart from bouldering, for which they use the Font scale, and big Alpine routes, for which they use the UIAA scale, and mixed sport climbing, for which they use the M scale) and the British use it for sport climbing, where seriousness isn't a factor. I’ve been hiking longer, increasingly difficult terrain, and finding routes that require scrambling. As an experienced rock climber who occasionally forays into mountaineering, I get burned on fitness `10/10 times. Tinkerham Peak at Snoqualmie pass is a short scramble that is non technical and can be done in a morning. Even routes of the same technical Grade can feel quite different. It is rated at 5. Rundle Traverse in the Canadian rockies. I don't know how actual climbing where you need hands and feets is described, maybe as rock climbing or ice climbing. Class 3. Longer story, I have vivid memories of the first time I went rock climbing some time in the late 80's: it was terrifying. Anyway, learn rope skills from a climbing instructor, and go climbing. They’re normally considered separate activities from regular hiking, which is when you walk along trails and only occasionally need to use your hands to pull yourself up over an obstacle. A rope is often used. After climbing for a year and a half I still get scared on the first climb then it starts to go away. Ellinore gives you a flavor of the Olympics. Both are Diff. a lot of indoor gym climbing and a little outdoor bouldering so I'm planning to do Mount. It's basically a running vest with a 24L stuff sack on the back. If I had any intention of climbing with a partner and possibly needing to rope up, I’ll bring something else. A fall could be fatal. A lot of mountain summits can include scrambles. I am not into 100% scrambling. 148 votes, 52 comments. Be safe, start early, check the weather, and keep a level head and you’ll be fine. Simple climbing, often with exposure. Climbing requires more gear and training. In the UK, the difference between scrambling and hiking is similar: if you use your hands for stability, you’re hiking, if you use your hands for propulsion, you’re scrambling and if you use a rope, you’re climbing. 100% climbing will help. I would honestly suggest learning how to rock climb in a gym and gain confidence climbing vertically, up and down. Others might have an easy approach, but the descent could involve rappelling, scrambling, or down-climbing back to your start. I'vs been scrambling since I was a kid and have done grade 3's that took me several failed attempts and return trips, succeeded on alpine 5. Even gym climbing teaches you about body positioning and moving in balance. Hahaa. I'm looking for an approach shoe for scrambling about in the mountains and have been coming across lots of conflicting info. Sport climbing scares me more because I dont like being around other groups of people at gyms and crags. Short story, the fear related to scrambling gets better with training, repetition and confidence. Idk where you are scrambling, but while scrambling you typically aren't bringing a rope or harness or even considering the option of a belay. If you’re running a climbing gym, shutting down prospective customers is a terrible business model. Apr 29, 2025 · Sure, some climbs are just a stone’s throw from the car. Class 5: Is considered technical roped free (without hanging on the rope, pulling on, or stepping on anchors) climbing; belaying, and other protection hardware is used for safety. No matter what, the best approach shoes combine the stability and support of a hiking boot with the grip and dexterity of a climbing shoe. Scrambling and climbing are two activities that people do in the mountains. Scrambling will cover basic low-class rock travel skills and basic snow skills with ice axe usage. So with that in mind practice route reading and try to flash problems. Up to the chain section is fine but some exposure after with a bit of down climbing. They are comfortable, breathable, and have tons of grip for scrambling (even on wet rock). r/coloradohikers A chip A close button A chip A close button Nov 7, 2023 · The approach can be anything from a short scramble to the crag or a multi-day hump to a valley of granite towers and anything in between. Falls may well be fatal. If you're not a climber or don't have true climbing experience, I would not recommend the tetons. Class 4 in the YDS is rock climbing. You can climb your local Hill, you can climb Eiger Northface. The idea of a climbing shoe is that you want your toes together to provide more support on small edges. I'm also a fan of the Ecrin Roc. It teaches you to follow someone else on their mountaineering trip. The class rating is somewhat subjective and the boundaries between classes can be a bit fuzzy, but this is a general overview. Take the direct route (aka winter route) for more of a scramble. Also temperature is a big thing for me. Each has their own skill set that will help with scrambling. Climbing with a rope is the easiest way to train your brain as you still get the feeling of being up there but the risk is mitigated. However, I don't enjoy indoor gym climbing or the training for sport climbing (hangboarding, etc) and the nearest crags are quite far away. hi all! my friend and i are planning a four day, three night camping/hiking trip in late may. If you dont need a goal with glacier travel, theres scrambles and rock climbing mtns that are more than walks. Scrambling; hands are used for balance; a rope might be carried. In this review, we compare 11 of the best models on the market today in side-by-side tests. climber and UL backpacker here. And that was top roping! But there some something about the singular focus it created. Others may require fourth or low fifth-class scrambling to reach the base of the first pitch. I'm just not sure how it would be to clip them to a harness. I suggest you take the Alpine Scrambling course, spend a subsequent year or two in the mountains, then decide whether to sign up for the Basic Climbing course. They aren't ultralight, but they were super cheap, the grips grip, and they pack pretty well in a technical pack for climbs. Scrambling vs Bouldering – Are They the Same? Jan 9, 2024 · Scrambling is moving over rocks and may require hikers to use their hands to continue on a trail. we visited joshua tree in october and LOVED scrambling on all of the rocks while doing little hikes. There are some heady portions of scrambling, exposure related, that you have to just live with. See full list on trailandcrag. Off to the Lakes gets you Striding Edge, Jacks Rake. But logistically that's different than a simple scramble in my mind. ), but it should all start from a solid base of scrambling. Semantics are indeed weird. I am not strong at anything btw and only really do snow/ice climbing and scrambling to satisfy my needs (just started recently). Hopefully my copy paste kept enough formatting. Scrambling course includes ice axe use (arrest, self-belay) but not glacier travel. These work but are not as good at technical scrambling. It took a little bit of time (couple months) for me to feel comfortable on normal 30' - 50' climbs on top rope. 7's due to bad feelings only to get caught in an unexpected storm soon after we were back on flat ground “Climbing” in the comment you’re replying to means rope climbing. Sep 15, 2024 · Class 5 of Scrambling. That’s where approach shoes enter the picture. Just wanted to clarify that in my post that scrambling is the additional feature as I cannot take multiple shoes in my rucksack for every terrain and activities. I do not know whether the current Scrambling course includes crampon use. I can understand maybe soloing sections and then roping up for higher 5th class bits. If you start left, I’d recommend wearing climbing shoes instead of scrambling shoes, at least until you really learn to trust your feet in scrambling shoes. i'm wondering It’s “weather” if you count all of mountaineering, slip-and-falls in rock climbing specifically, and you can’t even count rappelling as “while climbing” because it’s not while climbing. The grade/class is a function of how difficult the climbing is, not exposure. The RAD line is absolutely a no climbing line. Almost all approach shoes sacrifice comfort for a stiff(er) sole and a pointed toe box. Both roped and bouldering. The weight doesn't bother me at all and I'm happy to have something where I don't really need to worry about durability. For technicality the first consideration is whether I am going to be on or off trail. In the same thread, rock climbing would make you safer in the mountains because it gives you an extra skillset. Scrambling is climbing that no-one would normally consider climbing in the standard belayer/ leader way- you might wear harnesses and take a rope and a few bits of gear “just in case” but you wouldn’t rope up at the bottom and climb it in pitches. Posted by u/bafetimmserman - 8 votes and 20 comments Climbing is very broad term that is used for basically everything. When I started lead climbing about 5 months in the fear came back in a big way. You can have 5th class climbing that is not exposed (the boulder problem on the last pitch of the Beckey Route on Liberty Bell, for example), and you can have 3rd class climbing that is extremely exposed, like summit scrambles on pinnacles or the catwalk traverse on Hood. There is no climbing involved and there's no snow. Its iconic. Class 4 is much steeper, and while I liken it to climbing a ladder, it may go up 400 feet. I never had ambition to do very technical climbs or rock climbing, but I started climbing in a gym several years ago and was way, way more comfortable on scrambly and semi-technical terrain because of it. If you're in class 1-4 it's scrambling but if you're in class 5 it's free soloing. in the US by climbing grade, the generally defines scrambling as Class 2 or 3 in the Yosemite Decimal System. Sahale is worth looking into for one with an easy glacier + scrambling Adams is largely a walk but its also no joke, and worth doing sometime Mountaineering: pick 2 or 3 - walking, climbing, snow/ice skills Hiking San Gorgonio via the Vivian Creek Trail in the summer, for example, is not mountaineering because it's all trail. Yamnuska is a true scramble. On Reddit, the difference between mountaineering and alpinism is mostly gatekeeping. Jul 21, 2023 · Basic climbing skills: Scrambling incorporates elements of both hiking and rock climbing, so learning a few basic climbing techniques can help you move more smoothly. I've heard them described as being most useful for when the scrambling/rock portions are longer than the "hiking" portions of your day. If you don't have much outdoor experience or rock/snow travel skills, scrambling may be your best bet. Bouldering is also climbing. Class 4: Simple climbing, with exposure. A lot of more seasoned climbers consider low 5s to be scrambling too. Scrambling vs. Natural protection can be easily found. Rule of thumb: anything that's only class 1 (YDS) is just hiking. So roping up is extremely a good idea. Take up sport climbing. I second buying Alan Kane's book/books "Scrambles in the canadian rockies. If I am off trail I will almost always take boots. What would a scrambling partner even do if one falls? Top 5% of largest communities on Reddit. I prefer them to climbing shoes for easy 5th and below because after hours in even descent sloppy moccasin-type climbing shoes, my toes need a break. In a class 2-3 YDS we literally don't use safety equipment. The noise and stares make me uncomfortable. The main rappel runs down to an exposed corner then vertically drops. They aren't terribly bulky, but they aren't super lightweight either. Mt. Look into getting a permit for Mt. Helens. In many ways, professional climbers and guidebook authors set the tone for the climbing community. I'm currently looking at the Arcteryx Konseal FL 2 Leather GTX, Scarpa Gecko, and LS TX2 Evo. free soloing: The language of pro climbers. Eventually the Cuillin Ridge on the Isle of Skye - you're now crossing over into climbing territory, the full traverse will require a rope, some protection and some abseil kit (V Diff max climbing as I recall) but probably the finest scrambling day in the UK Class 1 is easy trails, class 2 is difficult trail or no trail, class 3 is scrambling, class 4 is very steep scrambling/easy climbing, class 5 is full rock climbing. Also note that climbing on one particular boulder is totally prohibited in Garden of the Gods. Scrambling is how I got into mountaineering because on the one hand it pushes you to improve your technical climbing ability (because climbing unroped is easier when you are good at climbing with a rope!) as well as moving higher onto glaciers and snow slopes, where some of the rope-work and equipment from rock climbing also come in handy. They are tough and require some level of expertise to summit. Basically, scrambling is climbing 10 feet above the ground. The mountaineers scramble course isok. Falls could easily be fatal. To me, scrambling, is like that steep rocky slope climbing you could easily master as a kid. Skip to main content. The new West Col descent is great, makes it way more doable. It is more of a hike than a scramble on the summer route. Not sure I would call this a beginner scramble. Reply reply More replies The joey is amazing to wear when doing hard climbing or for fast scrambling/mountain running missions. The average person realistically couldn’t climb an outdoor V0/1 their first day ever trying climbing. (I use la sportive tx4s anywhere on freeway but i know many people who use climbing shoes) Also come to the boulder climbers meetup at movement Monday and Thursday after work. This could include learning how to maintain three points of contact on the rock, developing a better sense of where your body is in space, and practicing specific techniques like I’m on the same trajectory as you. This is beyond the scope of this article and requires extensive training and experience. Basic covers basic rock climbing and glacier travel skills. Class 3 YDS means a fall and serious bodily injury and death. May 13, 2025 · If my arms are helping me move upward, that’s a climb. Key points: -Main Rappel is 30m -Average time to complete is 18 hours -No technical climbing involved (rappel only) Feb 11, 2025 · Approach shoes are designed to be durable enough to hike, scramble, and even do some lite climbing before you change into your rock shoes. We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. ” In his view, it’s not the technical grade that defines scrambling—it’s how the movement feels. Really, mountaineering is the culmination of many many different mountain skills (rock climbing, trad anchors, rope skills, ice climbing, hiking, etc. I really like rock climbing so I tried to suppress it. A common way people think of scrambling is if you're climbing easy, trivial for you, moves even if there is some exposure. Stuart, Black Peak, and Del Campo are some options. We are not talking about scrambling anymore; it’s is full-blown rock-climbing territory. Other tips for a scramble (once again depending on scoring) is warm up on easier problem’s and save some easier stuff for the end (if it’s aggregated score, if it’s If you want even more challenging climbing, likely more difficult than a "grade 1 scramble", I would say head to the tetons. That being said, I’m definitely keeping that line in mind since the versatility of emergency line that can catch a fall and not cause awful things to happen is certainly intriguing. It is mostly a synonym for summiting. Start small and build your confidence. I've posted in a few hiking threads on here about scrambling and people seem to want to know more about it, so I thought I'd… Posted by u/[Deleted Account] - No votes and 15 comments I enjoy scrambling (up to grade 3 UK/III UIAA) and would like to prepare a little better for the summer months. However, knowing when a scramble turns into a rock climb is essential. ezm cftr ogdoe rcle vzzccovf vgwi efys goi cwrpx vurx